Monthly Archives: January 2012

Why I Do What I Do

Hey there. I’m Chris. You might know me from Twitter (@lansdellicious), from my articles on ManaDeprived and the WrongWayGoBack network or from the large number of podcasts on which I’ve appeared. If that’s how you know me, then you likely consider me loud, opinionated, occasionally crude, maybe obnoxious and definitely a happy-go-lucky kind of guy. Whatever your thoughts or opinion, I very much doubt that you would say I do not love this game. And about a year ago you wouldn’t have recognised me at all. That was before Magic: the Gathering saved my life.

It’s a funny thing to think of, really: a grown man of thirty-three years crediting a collectible card game with saving his life. I mean, it’s just a game right? It’s not like I have some Chapinesque story of making it to the Pro Tour and the World championships and revolutionising the term “Magic community” after being incarcerated. I didn’t secure my dream job with Wizards having slaved away at other companies designing B-list games. I didn’t go from pillar of the community to R&D intern. I’m just a random durdle who’s not even particularly GOOD at Magic. How on earth could it have saved my life?

You’d need a fair amount of back story to understand that. I’ve lived a pretty crazy life and I’ve often been told I should write a book about it. I’ve lived in 3 different countries, visited many others, hurtled head-long from crisis to crisis and seen more in my life so far than many people ever will. Or so I’m told. I don’t know about all that, but I will try and give you some idea of what got me to the point where Magic did what it did.

A Little History

I got into Magic in 1997 while working at a major video game retailer in the UK. The game introduced me to the gamer culture and gave me a social circle, something which had been lacking for me since my move from Barbados to England a couple of years earlier.

In November of 2010 I left my wife of 11.5 years. I had been unhappy in the marriage for at least 3 years prior but never had the courage or the self-confidence to leave. I was also scared of the ramifications for our son and for my finances. We got married way too young (I was 20) and she had lied to me about several things, mainly that she had been accepted to Cambridge University. At the time I was living in England and she was in Newfoundland, Canada. Through the jigs and reels we realised it would be easier for me to move to Canada than the other way around, so I did. I’m a smart guy, a gamer and a sportsman, a geek and a jock. She was (and still is) a typical teenager, all into partying and spending money and being irresponsible.

She was also incredibly insecure…and not at all intelligent. That sounds very harsh but unfortunately it is also very true, as anyone who knows her will attest. I had a hard time getting her to actually discuss anything meaningful, and she would never debate me on anything. My brain slowly atrophied. Her insecurity got to the point where I wouldn’t even go for a drink with the guys because she didn’t trust me. To be more accurate, she didn’t trust her ability to hold on to me.

About 5 years ago we relocated so I could get a better job. I thought maybe it would save us, and for a while things got better. It didn’t last long. I briefly got back into Magic through MTGO, but money once again hauled me out. I was fast becoming a beaten-down shadow of myself. I had fundamentally changed to the point that I didn’t even recognise myself. On my 30th birthday (in 2009), which we spent in England, I resolved to get my identity back. I told myself that it had been 10 years and I was not going to give up on my marriage now. I made some changes and for a while I thought it was making a difference. That lasted about a month, maybe two. Then things got worse than before.

In the summer of 2010 I met someone. I’m not proud of what happened with her but she changed my life. She made me feel wanted, she encouraged me and she basically filled all the gaps in my marriage. She was married too and also unhappy. She left her husband before I left my ex and things got even more intense as she started pressuring me to leave. Eventually I found the courage to do what I should have done years before and leave my wife…and then things started to get REALLY bad.

The more freedom I had (my ex didn’t move out until January of this year) the further this new interest pulled away. A close friend of hers, about whom she had lied to me before, left his fiancée and needed somewhere to stay. She offered her couch. She swore blue blind, up and down that nothing was happening between them…and of course it was. However it was almost 2 months until I found out. Two months of us making plans for kids, spending our lives together, moving to another province and generally planning out the rest of our lives. She made me feel like I was her soul mate, and I felt she was mine. I discarded the fake identity I painted on myself to save my marriage and then became who I thought I really was. The problem is that this new identity was also a fake, although to a lesser degree. When she told me she had been sleeping with this guy all along, I was devastated. I had just built myself back up and she tore me right back down again. Only this time I was further down.

I was a mess. I hardly got off the couch, I never went anywhere but work or to buy groceries. I hardly ate. When I did try and socialise it was blatantly obvious that I was desperate for attention and it went nowhere. My family tried their best to help, but they were in England. The timing could not have been worse because the people I considered to be close friends were all going through their own crises and could not help. That didn’t stop them from leaning on me of course, which in turn sent me further into the doldrums. If you’ve never been in this state, you can’t fully appreciate just how hard it is to escape. You find a positive and try to grasp on to it, but then something minor happens that sets you back to square one. It’s really easy to sit back now and see that I was an idiot and brought it all on myself, but that seems largely irrelevant. It happened, and I was not dealing with it at all correctly.

“Depths of despair” is such a ridiculous cliché, but it fairly accurately describes where I found myself. Something had to give: either I was going to dig myself out, or I was going to become a recluse. My son, who until this point had been the lone bright spot and the only thing to which I was grasping, then decided that he didn’t want to spend time with me any more and that everything was my fault. I discovered that I actually hadn’t hit rock bottom before, because I sunk even lower. Without him in my life, what did I have? What was the point? Why was I working, why did I get out of bed every day?

Magic’s Back

Shortly before my wife and I split up, I had bought a new BlackBerry which had a native podcast app. Just for fun I had decided to see if anyone was doing Magic podcasts. The MTGCast feed came up and I discovered that yes, yes they were. Many of them. I downloaded The Eh Team due to them being Canadian, and it was the episode with Marshall and Mike Flores on it. That led to me downloading Limited Resources and Top 8 Magic, and I was hooked on podcasts from that point on. This would become essential at this stage, as it was really the only outlet I had left for mental exercise.

Despite not having played Magic for years, I still checked every now and then to see what was going on in the game. I’ve heard it said that we never truly quit Magic, we jut take a break from time to time. Those breaks vary in length but sooner or later everyone comes back. I had MTGO still installed on my laptop, though it hadn’t been updated since Alara block. One night I decided to fire it up and sit through the updates (seriously, they take forever…) and see what was going on in the online world. I had just discovered CommanderCast and The Avant Card Show and so I was curious to try this “new” EDH format. Cash was tight so I built a deck with the cards I had and ventured into a game. It was like I had never left.

Those of us who play Magic every day can often take for granted how incredible this game is. On the surface it’s a collectible card game that requires you to build your own decks and play them against other people and their own decks. The vast majority of Magic players never think about the game as anything more than that, even if it is a social outlet for them. For me, at this stage in my life, Magic was a way to express my creativity. I could use these cards to build decks that were uniquely me, and then pit them against others who were (ostensibly at least) doing the same thing. Win or lose, I was doing something that nobody else could do: playing MY deck. That was huge for me at a time where I felt completely without value or importance.

I was also doing something I hadn’t had a chance to do in many years: think. My relationship with my ex was so stifling for my intellectual side that I had forgotten everything I knew about resource management, planning ahead, threat assessment, situational evaluation and calculation of odds. Magic requires all these things, and the more you play the more they develop. As you play at more competitive levels these skills go from being an advantage to a requirement to compete. I used to be very good at all of these things, but like any other skills they atrophied as I wasn’t using them. One of my traits is a desire to learn and to think and to use my head, and having been denied the opportunity to do these things for so long I took to them like rain on a parched garden. Unfortunately that metaphor proves all too appropriate as it has taken me almost a year to get close to the level at which I found myself previously.

Through podcasts and through actually playing the game, Magic was providing me with entertainment. I am fortunate to have a job that allows me to spend vast chunks of time with headphones on, so the job I hated became much more bearable when I could work AND learn about Magic at the same time. At night when I got home, I would put the new knowledge to use and get my entertainment from the practical side. There are not many card games that allow you to get as much enjoyment from theorycrafting as you do from playing, but the nature of Magic and the sheer enormity of the card pool and the possibilities make it a very realistic proposition. People like Mike Flores have made a name and something of a living by doing just that. When you add the magic of Twitter to the list, I had non-stop contact with the Magic community and all the various aspects of it.

Magic was also a social outlet. Without ever having to leave my beige microfibre prison, I had contact with other people. I had conversations, arguments and fun times. Sure it’s a suboptimal way to interact with people, but it was a HUGE step up from messing around with Facebook games and feeling sorry for myself. Once again Twitter made this easier; putting me in direct contact with people I otherwise would never have known or even heard of. Interacting with others “in the real” stopped being something to fear and started feeling natural again. Even though I’ve never had a problem expressing emotions, there appears to be some sort of “guy gene” that makes us uncomfortable with appearing weak in front of our peers. Being able to converse with others without worrying about that made it easier for me to manage these issues and enabled me to reintegrate myself into something approaching a normal life. That was still a way off though, but at least I wasn’t spending all my time wallowing in self-pity. Just most of it. It was going to take time, but at that point I didn’t even think of it in that way. For the time being it was just something else to do.

The Long Road Back

Then the catalyst got added to the mixture. Bryan, Christian, Debbie and Marc from the Avant Card Show put on a contest for their podcast. Well, I say contest but it was really a thinly-veiled way to get some ideas for show topics. Not even considering the possibility that I would win, I put in a suggestion and…well, I did win. I got an email from the hosts, inviting me on their cast and explaining the way things worked. I think I was on the bus at the time I got the email, and I went directly to Circuit City to buy a headset which, incidentally, has died. I am on my third now. Wore them out I guess. I was a big fan of these guys and when the day finally came (it was a Monday…) I was nervous as hell. It was like meeting a celebrity for me. The cast was (alas, it is now defunct or at the very least on extended hiatus) focused on the casual player so I could afford to be a little wrong on some things and I didn’t actually need to have a clue about metagames and what was actually good. Thank God. Some would say I STILL don’t have a clue about that stuff.

The cast was the best 4+ hours I had spent in many months. I laughed, genuinely laughed and felt happy doing so, for the first time in weeks. I was interacting with real people and more to the point, real people who I admired. They treated me like a friend, chatted with me for a couple of hours after we’d finished recording and just generally gave me a great evening. They also infected me with two dangerous viruses: the judging virus and the podcasting virus. So yeah, blame Bryan and Debbie in particular. All their fault.

To be honest I had been considering starting my own podcast for a while before going on Avant Card. The only skill I have that I’ve never questioned is my ability with words, both written and spoken. The problem was that I was a nobody. OK I guess I still am, but less of one than I was at this point. It wasn’t until I heard Jack and Adena on a call-in episode of Monday Night Magic, both saying they were available for new podcasts, that I really put the plan into action. Noyan was recommended by Joey Pasco, and away we went!

To summarise where we are so far and to put it in chronological order, since this is getting a little Pulp Fiction-y: Marriage on the rocks. Discovered Magic podcasts. Marriage ended. Got back into Magic through MTGO. Became addicted to podcasts. Played even more Magic online. Got engrossed in the Magic Twitterverse. Won a “contest” to get on a podcast. Went on podcast, became infected with the podcast bug and the judge bug. Started a new podcast. Relationship with new partner blew up in unpleasant fashion.

This is where Magic’s value really started paying off. The worse I felt, the more I immersed myself in this new community. Like Mike Flores and Jonathan Medina before me, I am not shy about self-promotion and I know how to get my name out there. Through Twitter I wrangled my way on to some other podcasts and built a listener base for Horde of Notions. The more success I had, the better I felt. Talking to and learning from other Magic players was deepening my already profound love for the game, which naturally made me want to do more for it.

Then it was time for Nationals qualifiers. Up until this point I had been playing exclusively online, so my paper collection was anything but Standard-legal. All I had was some leftovers from various older sets and previous aborted attempts to get back into the game. However it felt like a big and important step, getting myself socially integrated with real people again, and I really wanted to see if I could have more success in paper than online. Enter Medina. I’m fairly sure I first heard of this guy on The Eh Team, and I knew his reputation. I needed a deck, I knew he could provide one. So I emailed back and forth with him a bit and settled on Elves. Caw Blade was a little out of my price range, but I knew fast green dudes had a good shot at beating Jace. The deck arrived, fully sleeved and with full-art Zendikar basics I might add, in plenty of time for the tournament.

I missed top 8, but the infection was complete. I was now back into Magic fully and wholly. The players at my local game store are, by and large, a good group of guys and I had a blast hanging out and playing the game with them. I also noticed that the community here needed help, mainly from someone who could become a judge and bring some higher-level tournaments to the area. Becoming a judge then was my obvious next step.

Even at this point I felt a sense of debt to the Magic community as a whole. I was emerging from my depression and I knew that it was the game and the people involved with it that were to thank for that. Be it on MTGO, through the MTGCast network, on Twitter or through the numerous articles I read each week, there is a real sense of camaraderie that welcomed me, by and large, with open arms. Come home, brother. You are wanted here. Becoming a judge to enable my local community to grow seemed like the best way to give back.

The woes of the Magic community in Newfoundland have been spoken about repeatedly on my various podcast appearances, so I will not go into too much detail here. We have a level 2 judge who is banned from our only WPN store, and at the time he was the only judge in town. That makes it tough to get certified. I had chatted with Bryan about the issue and he put me in touch with Charlotte, an L2 from Ontario, who helped mentor and prepare me for my test. I flew up to Toronto for Nationals (which was far from cheap) and took my test there, under the watchful eye of Charlotte. As we know, I passed.

Becoming a judge may well have helped, but I think Nationals was the final push that opened the doors and let the light back in for me. It was at the time the biggest Magic event I had attended, and it was amazing. Thanks to the incredible kindness of The Eh Team’s Scotty Mac I was able to play a few grinders, play a ton of Commander, watch my friends crash and burn and just generally hang out and immerse myself in the geek culture. I was back.

Thank You.

This is not a journey I could have made alone. I have so many people to thank for their help and support in bringing me through:

  • Bryan, Debbie and Christian from Avant Card for giving me my start, being hilarious and encouraging me to seek out judgehood.
  • KYT from ManaDeprived and The Eh Team for giving me a shot at writing, being a good friend and always supporting my ventures
  • ScottyMac of The Eh Team for being an amazing friend, inviting me on the show and just generally being one of the nicest and most generous guys you’ll ever meet.
  • Jonathan Medina for providing me the means to get into the game, for occasionally slapping some sense into me and for being a whole lot nicer than you might think he is.
  • Jay Boosh of The Eh Team and Public Enemies for being a mix of Scotty, Dr. Jeebus and Medina. Yup, that should piss him off just enough.
  • Jack LaCroix, for helping me get started in this crazy world and for pushing my profile at every opportunity. Another real, true friend who would do anything to help.
  • Tangent and Robert, erstwhile of ManaScrewed and now of Public Enemies and The Men of Magic respectively, for inviting me on their show and starting my “Lansdell is on every podcast” run
  • Bryan (again), Charlotte and the denizens of the #fljudge IRC channel for throwing countless daggers at me and preparing me for my judge tests
  • Kyle Ryc, Regional Co-ordinator for Canada, for helping me grow Magic in Newfoundland and being as passionate about community as I am
  • Trevor, Ken, Mev, Blair, Crocker, Mike, Mark and all the rest of the local players who made me feel like part of the gang pretty much from day 1
  • Marshall and Ryan, the original Limited Resources guys, for constantly putting out quality and for giving me a goal to aim at
  • Patrick Chapin, for being so open about his setbacks and his journey back to the top and for inspiring me to do the same. And for coming on my show.
  • Finally, Wizards of the Coast. This game is more than just a game, and without it I honestly don’t know where or who I would be.

    With all that the game has done for me, that this list has done for me, how can I not do everything I can in return? Why wouldn’t I extol its virtues at every chance, why wouldn’t I help any and everyone I can who is getting started in the community, be it a new player or a new podcast? After everything you’ve all done for me, how can I do less in return?

    You know, I’ve been part of some pretty intense arguments about Magic through digital media. There are people within the community I don’t particularly like. Sometimes it strikes me though: we are so damn lucky. We play a game that is so much more than just a game. We have almost daily meaningful interaction with the people who make the game. We’ve shown that we can influence the way the game is played, made and organised. If we’re good, we can make a living playing this game, selling this game, making this game. Our community helps its own: just in the last year we funded two trips for players, replaced stolen collections, donated large sums to charity and united to protect both our game and one of our biggest names (though some did so far too vigorously). We can make friends, find partners, get dream jobs and move on to bigger and better things because of this game. It develops our minds, our social skills, our leadership skills. Magic is so much more than “a child’s card game” or some geeky pastime. Magic saved my life.

  • Tagged

    Brewing in Draft – WB Synergy

    Innistrad draft has been widely acclaimed as one of the best draft formats ever, if not THE best. The green/white Travel Preparations deck is considered by most to be the strongest in the format, with the Spider Spawning and UW Tempo/Token deck also in the running. I think it’s a testament to the Limited environment in which we are operating. Although all of these decks are undeniably very good, they’re also very well known and people are always on the lookout for them.

    My rogue-brewing penchant is well known, and it extends to the draft format. In Innistrad I’ve had most of my success with a BW deck that is steeped in synergy an makes good use of some otherwise mediocre cards that you can often pick up late. It has a solid curve and can grind out a win just as easily as it can stomp face. Let’s look at some of the cards you want to pick up.

    Key Pieces
    The cards you really need to make the engine work.

    Village Cannibals, Unruly Mob, Thraben Sentry – These guys often go mid- to late pack and are they keys to all the synergy in the deck. There are a lot of Humans that you don’t mind killing, and these guys really don’t mind you killing them.

    Falkenrath Noble – One of the best creatures in the format. Mini-drains every time something dies are good in any black deck, but here where you are often killing your own stuff it really shines. They also allow you to block more aggressively, always taking the trades where you can get them and letting some guys through if there’s no favourable block. Noble often makes players reconsider swinging in, which gives you time to find more synergy.

    Doomed Traveler, Mausoleum Guard – This should not be a surprise. These guys are good in almost any white deck, but they really shine here. I am not above attacking with these guys just to get them killed, then Rebuking them in the End of Combat step if they aren’t killed.

    Rebuke, Victim of Night, Slayer of the Wicked – Seems obvious that removal is good, but here they can serve a dual purpose.

    Nice to have
    These are the cards that go well in the deck, but you can get by without them.

    Selfless Cathar, Silverchase Fox – Two efficient creatures that have a useful sac ability but in this deck can make for some intriguing combat maths. You shouldn’t have trouble picking either one up late.

    Demonmail Hauberk – A lot of people HATE this card. Nobody denies that +4/+2 is a huge bonus, but sacrificing a dude is a big loss, especially with the potential of being blown out by a timely Smite the Monstrous. That said, it is rather ridiculous in this deck.

    Altar’s Reap, Disciple of Griselbrand – Both of these enable instant-speed sacrificing for a benefit, and make combat maths hard for your opponent. If you have BB untapped not many people are expecting you to sacrifice an attacking creature to flip your Sentry, buff your Cannibal and Mob AND draw two cards. It’s just not on the radar for a lot of players.

    Unburial Rites – Often goes early, and is by no means essential in your deck, but if you can get one then your Falkenrath Noble is going to do double- or triple-duty. Seems good.

    Rares and Mythics
    You won’t always get them, but they’re nice to have. This deck benefits from not actually NEEDING any rare bombs to be very good, but these all go well in the deck. I won’t add obvious first-pick bombs here (like Olivia) unless they are markedly better in the deck.

    Reaper from the Abyss – Definitely gets better in this deck. Creatures are GOING to die in this deck, and likely every turn. It might occasionally be right to kill off your OWN creatures with his ability.

    Skirsdag High Priest – Sacrificing a Mausoleum Guard is good. Doing it with this guy active is just better.

    Playing the deck

    Although on the face of it this is a pretty straightforward deck, there are some tricks here that you need to keep in mind. With all the sacrificing and growing that can and should be going on, doing so at the right time is very important.

    Sacrificing a Selfless Cathar is one of the most important tricks in the deck and possibly the most powerful. For some reason people often overlook it, even though it’s an onboard trick. They either forget the +1/+1 or forget the counters it’s going to get you.

    Elder Cathar is a really strong card here. You’re playing a lot of Humans so more often than not you’re going to get the two counters. When you attack (which should almost always be en masse to make the maths as hard as possible for the opponent) he becomes very difficult to block effectively. When blocking, throwing him in front of something with first strike can actually be a huge benefit for you.

    I mentioned attacking en masse, and the reasons are various. For one thing you have hopefully snagged a couple of Village Bell-Ringers, and that’s just a blowout in any deck. You’ve also got tricks to turn a tapped creature into an untapped blocker or two, and leaving back a High Priest and another guy can make attacking even more hazardous for the opponent. Bluffing Rebuke can also make your opponent more conservative, and the Noble is another scary card to deal with.

    Overall what we have is a powerful engine with a ton of synergy that can slot in with most of the good, strong rares in the colours. It’s also a blast to play. Have fun!

    The Cream Always Rises To The Top (An Apology)

    I’m a fucking hypocrite.

    After the extended Twitter drama of the last few days (some would say it’s non-stop drama) I started writing a long, emotional entry about how I was misinterpreted and misquoted and how shitstorms seem to always arise around me even though I didn’t do anything wrong. I’m not here to confirm or deny that, though I will say it was written in a very bad state at the end of a very bad four-day stretch and should be taken with a very large pinch of salt.

    A very good friend of mine recently told me that writing is catharsis, and I do believe she’s right. Just putting the Twitter events down on digital paper helped me realise that although my points may have been valid, I was coming from a severely unstable and incorrect base. As a result I got into arguments with people I respect and people I consider friends, and I feel terrible about that.

    Let me bring you up to speed, in case you missed some or all of the discussion. The details are irrelevant at this point, but suffice it to say that the age-old argument of brewers vs. netdeckers came up again. Having listened to the latest Eh Team (a rare miss in my mind) in which the hosts and guest stated categorically that a certain card was bad, I felt the (perhaps irrational) need to defend said card. At no point was my name mentioned as a defender of the card, but something that has always rankled with me is people thinking that because they don’t like a card, it’s instantly bad. I pointed out the virtues of the card in something of a passive-aggressive way, and then the debate started.

    Jay Boosh is a friend of mine, I hope. He has a heart of gold and will do anything he can to help a friend…including giving them a much-needed smack in the chops when they are being pig-headed. His manner may be a little more gruff than some appreciate, but once you know what’s under it you look past that. One thing he is not, however, is willing to play any old card just on the say-so of any old player. And he’s far from alone there. A whole swath of players like to play decks that are recommended by players they trust and respect and that suit their play style. If you’re a brewer but you’re not on their list, they likely don’t want to try your idea. It hasn’t got enough credibility behind it. The cream will always rise to the top, with decks as well as with dairy products, and these decks have done so.

    As a brewer, I spend a lot of time (now, though I never used to) testing my ideas. One of the things I am trying to do is filter them so that I only start talking them up once I know they are good. I’m not there yet though. The next step for me, as Smitty so often said was the case for him on The Eh Team, is to get people to play my decks. Also like Smitty, I get frustrated when people write the idea off simply because it came from me…then turn around weeks later and play the same deck because a pro recommended it, all the while talking about how great the deck and its builder are. And sometimes, that frustration escapes.

    Over the past few weeks I’ve been lucky enough to talk to some true masters of the craft and have learned a great deal from them. That started with Mike Flores on episode 11 of Horde of Notions, and continued with Jon Finkel (episode 25) and Patrick Chapin (episode 27). You’d be hard-pressed to find three better deckbuilders when in their primes. They taught me a lot about their process and what goes in to every deck they build. You know what though? I’d heard much of it before.

    People like Jay, Nina, even Smitty had all told me a lot of the things that the masters were telling me. I ignored it…because they didn’t have the credibility or track record to make me want to listen to them. This realisation is especially jarring to me right now because although I consider Jay and Nina to be friends (and Nina has often had my back in discussions such as these, even if she does vastly overrate my skill), I flat-out look up to Smitty almost as much as I do the Chapins and Flores of the world. I am now where he was 8 months ago, and I’ve been following his path pretty much since I got back into the game. How I managed to ignore him is still a mystery to me. If I’m going to ignore advice from others on the basis of their reputation, who the hell am I to expect them to do things differently?

    Not to say my opinion on certain cards has changed. I believe people tend to rate cards in a vacuum or in a given meta, then not revise that rating as things change. That’s a trap. Magic isn’t played in a vacuum, and the quality of a card can and will change as the metagame changes. The list of cards from Scars block alone that are significantly better now then when they came out is rather long: Elspeth, Plague Stinger, Viridian Emissary, the Crusaders, Hero of Bladehold, Lashwrithe, Gut Shot, Vapor Snag, Volt Charge…these are just off the top of my head. There are several that are worse, too. To categorically say a card is bad, or “not a real card” when in fact it is winning events and showing well in others is just inaccurate. But it is patently unfair and hypocritical of me to get angry that people won’t put any trust in my ideas and opinions and won’t respect what I saw when I wasn’t willing to do the same for them.

    Jay, Nina, Jeph and anyone else I fought with over this: I’m sorry I got overheated and carried away. Opinions at the end of the day are just that, and you deserve more respect from me than you got.

    Brewers: Stop fighting everyone who says no to you. The way to get people to trust your decks is to win with them. If you can’t then ask yourself why. Is it because you’re a bad player, or because the deck itself is bad? Is it both? If the former, you have a tough road ahead. If the latter, scrap it and start again. Once you start winning, people will start trying it. Don’t worry what one or two people think just because they have the loudest opinion. In the end, the truth always rises. Just like the cream.

    Mayor? I hardly know ‘er!

    Mayor of Avabruck is a very powerful card that has yet to really make an impact outside of Limited. When played early it puts pressure on control decks to tap out to prevent it flipping, and against aggro decks it excels late game when they are often in top deck mode. In pairs they work REALLY well, especially flipped when they are churning out a pair of 4/4 Wolves each turn. It has plenty of weaknesses of course: it dies to the currently-ubiquitous Gut Shot, even flipped it dies to Brimstone Volley and Incinerate and it has no evasion. All of these things are true, but if you play the card in a blue shell with plenty of permission then some of those difficulties are mitigated.

    So we know we’re in green/blue, and we also know we want to be able to ship the turn without casting anything in order to flip our Mayors. We also want to ensure we have multiple Mayors in play, have ways to protect our Mayors and also have an alternate plan to win the game. That all sounds like we want a lot of instants, so Delver of Secrets would appear to be a natural fit. Mayor also pumps Delver, no matter which side is face-up. Cackling Counterpart lets us copy a flipped Mayor (or Delver) at instant speed, allowing for both combat tricks and responding to a flip-back trigger for the Mayor. We want a strong suite of counters, which conveniently flip the Delver as well. Frost Titan is not seeing a lot of play right now but seems fairly well-positioned and is also a great target for Cackling Counterpart.

    I had a pair of Runechanter’s Pike in the deck but I always found myself wishing they were something else. They are now Rampant Growths. I somehow only have 1 Dissipate online so I’m playing with Cancel instead, but if you’re going to make the deck then you really want Dissipates there. I’m also short 2 Hinterland Harbor. I’d consider Ludevic’s Test Subject, at least in the sideboard against decks that have trouble dealing with it (not decks running Vapor Snag or any black deck, basically) as it is a good early blocker that is great to copy when it flips.

    So, let’s get to the list!
    [cardlist title=Mayor Says No style=width:500px;layout:cardbox 2 right;category:tabbed 8;options:true false;]

    *4 Ponder
    *3 Rampant Growth
    *4 Disperse
    *4 Mana Leak
    *4 Cancel
    *4 Cackling Counterpart
    *1 Dissipate

    *4 Mayor of Avabruck
    *4 Delver of Secrets
    *2 Frost Titan

    *3 Ghost Quarter
    *9 Forest
    *12 Island
    *2 Hinterland Harbor

    *4 Flashfreeze
    *4 Steel Sabotage
    *2 Phyrexian Metamorph
    *1 Phantasmal Image
    *4 Moonmist

    Not the layout I was hoping for but I couldn’t get the one I wanted to work. The sideboard is a work in progress, the Moonmist feeling especially loose. Steel Sabotage has felt very good, however. The deck has trouble against mono-red, so Tree of Redemption might need to be in the board. You have enough counters to keep nasty things off the board, but dropping Mayor or Delver early is still sometimes the best play. Disperses help there but something like Quicksilver Geyser might be an option worth considering. Wow, there’s a sentence I never thought I’d write. Anyway, this is very much an FNM deck at best, but I’d love to hear your thoughts, advice and results with it. Have fun!